How do you read a poorly written ARC?

As a reviewer I come up against this problem now and again. When I receive an ARC I do expect to find some grammar and punctuation errors and try to keep my opinions about them to myself; after all I make my fair share of spelling mistakes on a daily basis. But what really irks me is when I receive an ARC that contains poor writing skills. Before a book goes out to even a reviewer there should be someone who has read it first, checking to make sure the book makes sense and is readable.
I bring this up because a few days ago I received an ARC from Harpers titled Proust’s Overcoat. It is the true story of one man’s obsession with collecting things the famed French author had owned. The book is small with only 120 pages but what a mess of a book it is!

In the first chapter the author talks about doing research on Proust for an Italian TV program. She interviews several people who knew him but does not seem to get the story she wants. Then she remembers a calling card she had belonging to a gentleman who collected Proust items. One of her associates goes out and interviews him. So far so good right? Well at the end of the chapter about the interview the author writes this paragraph “Early the next morning I was awoken by a ringing phone. It was Tosi, polite, discreet, to the point.’ I found the calling card. Guerin, the fellow’s name was Jacques Guerin’”.

What? Wait, Tosi already recanted his visit with this collector. Shouldn’t this paragraph come before the visit? I re-read the chapter thinking I may have missed something, but no, I did not. The flow did not make sense. Surely this was a mistake in the flow. I wondered how this got passed the first round of editing.
As I read on I found myself comparing the writing to a bad college paper. The author jumps from subject to subject and person to person without a break in chapters or even a break in paragraphs! I had to stop reading as it seemed the author tried to put in as much information in 120 pages a humanly possible without worrying if it made sense or if anyone would really care; by page 40 I found I did not.

So now I have a dilemma, do I review it based on what I read and criticize the writing or do I skip it all together? Dear Readers, what do you do when faced with a poorly written Arc?

Author: sarij

I'm a writer, lifelong bibliophile ,and researcher. I hold a Bachelors in Humanities & History and a Master's in Humanities. When I'm not reading or talking about Shakespeare or history, you can usually find me in the garden discussing science or politics with my cat.

5 thoughts on “How do you read a poorly written ARC?”

  1. I'm the last person to ask since I rarely review books and have never read an ARC in my life– but if you aren't obligated to review, why bother. Are you required to give the publisher/author feedback? If so, I would tell the truth in a tactful way– they need to know so they can edit properly. I just did a related post on bloopers in books– isn't that funny?! Great minds and all that…


  2. I believe in "telling it like it is", when it comes to reviewing books on my blog. Since I review ALL the books that I read, I'd have to share my thoughts . good luck Sari


  3. You are asked to overlook mistakes in ARC's because they are not yet corrected, but it can be heard to do when they are glaring. I really don't know what to advise you in your situation.I once read a book where any word or phrase in italics was missing. The book was set in China and the author used Chinese words and phrases throughout–all of which was in italics. There were so many blank spaces that no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't help but be put off by it. I probably would have liked the book better had that not been a problem. I guess the font they printed the ARC in doesn't include italics or something. I did say something in my review about it because it was too glaring and affected my reading too much for me not to.


Talk to me

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Amazing Waste

Repurposing Food and Reducing Waste


Shakespeare, Classics, Theatre, Thoughts

Nerd Cactus

Quirky Intellect for the Discerning Nerd

Self-Centric Design

The art of designing your life

The Ineluctable Bookshelf

Reading, writing, and states in between

Lizzie Ross

Reading, writing, dreaming


Stories of magic and mystery

Commonplace Fun Facts

a collection of trivia, fun facts, humor, and interesting notions.

Elan Mudrow



Fiction reviews, Bookblogger, Fiction book reviews, books, crime fiction, author interviews, mystery series, cover, love, bookish thoughts...

Patrick W. Marsh

I write about monsters to explore what it is to be human.

Shakespeare for Kids Books

Opening the door for kids to love Shakespeare and the classics


The 10-year Shakespeare New Year Resolution


Welcome to the world of cats!

The Book Reviews You Can Trust!

The Book Review Directory

For Readers and Writers


screams from the void

%d bloggers like this: